HIPAA Compliance in Print Operations of Hospitals and Healthcare Organizations

Featured Image

The stakes are incredibly high. Ensuring HIPAA compliance in the printing and copying operations of hospitals and healthcare organizations is no small feat. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) setting a high bar for the protection of sensitive patient information, and penalizes violations with significant fines. 

Paper printing and copying, fundamental yet often overlooked aspects of healthcare operations, are potential hotspots for compliance breaches. This article will cover essential elements and strategies for ensuring a HIPAA-compliant print environment at your healthcare organization.

Navigating HIPAA Compliance: The Critical Role of Managed Document Printing in Healthcare

What is HIPAA?

The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), established in 1996, serves as a cornerstone in the protection of patient health information (PHI). This legislation mandates the safeguarding of medical records and other personal health information, applying to all entities within the healthcare sector, including providers, payers, and their business associates. 

The primary goal of HIPAA’s is to ensure that individuals’ PHI is kept confidential and secure. This safeguards the interests of the patient, fosters trust in the healthcare system and enhances the overall quality of care.

The Three HIPAA Rules

  1. The HIPAA Privacy Rule outlines standards to protect all individually identifiable health information handled by covered entities or their business associates. A wide range of sensitive data, such as social security numbers, credit card information, and medical history, including prescriptions, procedures, conditions, and diagnoses, is considered protected health information (PHI). Ensuring patient data privacy is critical for protecting the patient from identity theft and other threats.
  2. The HIPAA Security Rule focuses on guidelines for securing electronic patient information ePHI). A key goal of this rule is to strike the proper balance that protects individuals’ private data while also allowing covered entities to leverage new technologies that improve the efficiency of patient care.
  3. The Breach Notification Rule requires covered entities (and their associates) to provide notification of any breach of unsecured protected health information. Covered entities are required to notify the affected individuals, the Secretary, and, in certain cases, the media. (Business associates must notify covered entities if a breach occurs at their end.)

HIPAA and Healthcare Print Operations

Maintaining HIPAA compliance is a complex challenge, particularly when it comes to the handling of printed documents. The printing, management, and disposal of documents containing PHI can easily become sources of HIPAA violations if not managed correctly. Such breaches not only compromise patient privacy but can also result in substantial financial penalties and damage to an organization’s reputation.

Here are some common ways in which mismanaged print operations can result in HIPAA violations:


Potential HIPAA Violations Related to Printed Documents:

  • Unauthorized access to printed patient records left unattended on printers.
  • Improper disposal of documents containing PHI, such as failing to shred before disposal.
  • Sharing of PHI without proper authorization, including accidental sharing due to misdirected print jobs.
  • Lack of controls on who can print PHI, leading to excessive, unnecessary printing and exposure risk.
  • Failing to maintain an accurate accounting of disclosures, including those made through printed documents.
  • Insufficient training on the secure handling of printed PHI, leading to mishandling or accidental disclosure.

Significant Incidents of HIPAA Violations and Consequences:

Affinity Health Plan
An incident where photocopiers containing PHI were returned to leasing agents without erasing the data, affecting over 344,000 individuals. The organization faced a $1.2 million fine for its HITECH rule violation. 

Cignet Health
Cignet Health faced a fine of $4.3 million for denying 41 patients access to their medical records, highlighting the importance of properly managing requests for printed PHI. This was the first Civil Money Penalty (CMP) related to HIPAA. 

University of Rochester Medical Center
A lost flash drive containing unencrypted PHI of patients led to a $3 million settlement, underscoring the risk associated with portable storage of digital documents.

Texas Health and Human Services Commission
Received a $1.6 million penalty for exposing PHI due to an unsecured online server, demonstrating the digital-to-print vulnerabilities.

A case where a laptop containing PHI was stolen, resulting in a $2.5 million settlement. This incident points to the risks involved in the transfer and printing of PHI from mobile devices.

New York Presbyterian Hospital and Columbia University Medical Center
A shared network server error resulted in the leak of 6,800 patients’ PHI, costing a collective $4.8 million in fines,illustrating the complexities of digital and printed PHI management.

Strategies to Avoid HIPAA Violations Related to Document Printing:

  1. Implement strict access controls on printing devices to ensure only authorized personnel can print PHI.
  2. Update passwords regularly to prevent bad actors from gaining access to your devices.
  3. Implement “Follow-Me” printing – also called pull-printing. This two-step process requires the user to be physically at the printing device and authenticate their identity through a badge or card reader.
  4. Use secure print release functions to prevent printed documents from being left unattended.
  5. Regularly audit print logs to monitor for any unauthorized access or excessive printing of PHI.
  6. Establish clear protocols for the disposal of documents containing PHI, ensuring secure shredding processes are followed.
  7. Train all staff on the importance of HIPAA compliance, specifically focusing on the handling of printed documents.
  8. Integrate Managed Print Services (MPS) to oversee print operations, ensuring adherence to HIPAA regulations through advanced security features and monitoring.

The Liabilities of Unmanaged Printing in Healthcare

Unmanaged, disorganized, or unsupervised printing practices pose significant risks to HIPAA compliance. Without proper protocols and oversight, the likelihood of printed documents containing PHI being misplaced, left unattended, or improperly disposed of increases dramatically. Uncontrolled printing leads to bloat in budgets; and it can lead to unnecessary exposure of PHI. Documents are printed without a legitimate need multiply the risk of breaches. 

Implementing a robust MPS solution can address these challenges by introducing secure printing protocols, tracking and auditing print jobs, and ensuring that only necessary printing is conducted, thereby minimizing the potential for HIPAA violations.

MPS: An essential component of HIPAA compliance

The secure management of printed documents containing PHI is an essential component of HIPAA compliance in healthcare. By recognizing common violations related to document printing and adopting strategic measures to mitigate these risks, healthcare organizations can better protect patient privacy. 

Integrating MPS, reinforcing training on the secure handling of PHI, and maintaining vigilance over print operations are critical steps in upholding HIPAA’s mandate and ensuring the confidentiality and security of patient information in a complex healthcare landscape.


Why Managed Print Services (MPS) Matter in Healthcare

In healthcare, paper isn’t going away anytime soon. From patient charts and prescriptions to billing information and lab results, the volume of sensitive data being printed or copied is staggering. Each piece of paper carries a risk—whether it’s being left unattended on a printer, improperly disposed of, or falling into the wrong hands, the potential for HIPAA violations is everywhere.

Managed Print Services (MPS) offer a way to manage these risks head-on. MPS isn’t just about fixing printers or reducing paper jams; it’s about taking a strategic approach to managing every document that gets printed or copied, ensuring they’re handled securely and in compliance with HIPAA regulations. This means secure printing, user authentication, data encryption, and comprehensive tracking of print activity.

How MPS Facilitates HIPAA Compliance

NOTE: Not all MPS providers will have the focus, expertise and technical wherewithal to mitigate HIPAA compliance liabilities. Just like Flex Technology Group stands alone in our nationwide service coverage, industry expertise and sheer implementation muscle, we also stand above the competition in the ways we can assist with HIPAA. 

An efficient, robust MPS implementation can significantly streamline and secure print operations in several key ways:

Secure Print Release

This feature holds documents in a print queue until the authorized user releases them at the printer. This simple step prevents sensitive information from sitting unattended and accessible to anyone passing by.

User Authentication

MPS requires users to authenticate themselves before they can print or access documents. This ensures that only authorized personnel can print sensitive patient information, significantly reducing the risk of accidental or unauthorized disclosure.

Data Encryption

With MPS, data sent to printers is encrypted, protecting it from interception. This is crucial for maintaining the confidentiality and integrity of patient information as it moves through the network.

Audit Trails

MPS solutions keep detailed logs of who printed what and when. This not only aids in tracking compliance but also in investigating breaches should they occur.

Are You Sending Print Jobs Out?

As you tighten HIPAA compliance in printing operations, you should consider the risk associated with outsourcing healthcare printing. When healthcare organizations send out printing jobs, they lose a degree of control over the security of their patient information. By bringing printing in-house, healthcare providers can maintain tighter control over the entire printing process, from start to finish.

Is Your Cloud Storage HIPAA Compliant?

AWS, Azure, Backblaze, Box, Carbonite, Dropbox, Egnyte, Google Cloud & iDrive, are all trusted HIPAA-compliant cloud storage services care providers rely on. That said, the healthcare organization using such services needs to take all needed security measures to use these services securely. 

Some of these measures include:

  • Encrypting all data stored on the cloud, 
  • Logging all user activity,
  • Monitoring the system on an ongoing basis,
  • Using secure access control to make sure only authorized personnel have access,
  • Performing regular IT security assessments.

The Role of MPS in Enhancing Print Security and Compliance

Adopting Managed Print Services in healthcare goes beyond just ticking the boxes for HIPAA compliance. It represents a proactive step towards transforming the print environment into a secure, efficient, and compliant operation. MPS providers bring to the table advanced printing solutions and technologies, tailor-made for the unique challenges of healthcare.

By leveraging MPS, healthcare organizations can optimize their print operations, ensuring secure access to printers, efficient management of print volume, and robust protection of sensitive patient information. This strategic approach not only safeguards against HIPAA violations but also enhances operational efficiency, ultimately contributing to better patient care.

In the healthcare landscape, where patient data is as crucial as the care provided, the importance of a comprehensive Managed Print Services (MPS) strategy becomes even more important. This strategy not only fortifies the defenses against potential HIPAA violations but also paves the way for a more streamlined, cost-effective, and environmentally responsible print ecosystem within healthcare organizations.

Optimizing Your Print Environment with MPS

A well-implemented MPS solution does more than ensure compliance; it optimizes the entire print environment. By analyzing print behaviors and device utilization, MPS providers can recommend strategies to reduce unnecessary printing, thus lowering costs and minimizing waste. This optimization often includes the deployment of multifunction printers (MFPs) that consolidate the functionalities of printing, copying, faxing, and scanning into one device, further enhancing the security and efficiency of print operations.

Moreover, MPS can significantly reduce the IT burden within healthcare organizations. With MPS providers taking on the responsibility for device maintenance, software updates, and troubleshooting, healthcare IT teams can focus their expertise on more critical areas, such as enhancing patient care technology and strengthening overall IT infrastructure security.


Future-Proofing Healthcare Print Operations

As healthcare continues to evolve, so do the challenges associated with maintaining HIPAA compliance in print operations. MPS offers healthcare organizations a way to future-proof their print environments. With ongoing assessments and regular updates, MPS ensures that healthcare providers can adapt to changes in compliance regulations, technological advancements, and evolving patient care needs without compromising security or efficiency.

Moreover, MPS providers stay ahead of the curve, offering the latest in print security technology, from advanced encryption methods to biometric authentication and beyond. This commitment to innovation means that healthcare organizations can trust their MPS partner to safeguard their print operations against emerging threats and vulnerabilities.

Customized Solutions for Diverse Healthcare Needs

Understanding that no two healthcare organizations are the same, Flex Technology Group offers a customized approach to MPS, with solutions tailored to the specific needs and challenges of each facility. Whether it’s a large hospital network requiring robust document management systems or a small clinic needing secure yet straightforward printing solutions, our MPS strategy can adapt to serve the diverse landscape of healthcare providers.

A well-executed MPS strategy facilitates the smooth and secure transition of patient data from digital to print form, maintaining data integrity and confidentiality throughout the process. The Flex Technology Group approach extends to the integration with existing Healthcare Information Systems (HIS) and Electronic Health Records (EHR), optimized for EPIC and CERNER. 

We helped them consolidate over 50 servers into a single server, with a single dashboard for streamlined, easy operation management. We helped them optimize their print operation for Windows and EPIC. In the process, we saved this organization over $5 million per year. We helped another multi-location healthcare organization implement secure printing and faxing, full encryption and required authentication.

We helped them consolidate over 50 servers into a single server, with a single dashboard for streamlined, easy operation management. We helped them optimize their print operation for Windows and EPIC. In the process, we saved this organization over $5 million per year.

We helped another multi-location healthcare organization implement secure printing and faxing, full encryption and required authentication, saving them nearly a $1 million in annual operation costs. 

Empowering Healthcare Providers to Focus on What Matters Most

At its core, the adoption of Managed Print Services in healthcare is about more than just printers and copiers; it’s about empowering healthcare providers to focus on what matters most—delivering exceptional patient care. By entrusting the complexities of print management to MPS, healthcare organizations can alleviate the administrative burdens and risks associated with print operations, allowing them to dedicate more resources to improving patient outcomes and advancing healthcare innovation.

With over 29,000 satisfied customers nationwide, Flex Technology Group is your ideal strategic partner in achieving HIPAA compliance and enhancing print operations within healthcare. By embracing MPS, your healthcare organization can navigate the challenges of maintaining patient data confidentiality, reduce wasteful printing, optimize its print environment, and ultimately, elevate the standard of care they provide.